What’s in a name?

Back in 2024 the South Carolina legislature began a slow move towards greater brokerage transparency. Additional guidance was necessary in 2026. Additional requirements will take effect next May. These measures were needed to address an incremental shift to hiding behind catchy sales team names best suited for a reality show. It’s often hard to tell who’s the boss, much less the Broker-in-Charge who is ultimately responsible for the team or the brokerage owner(s) who deposit the commission checks. Franchise, corporate-owned or independent. Why does it matter?  It doesn’t happen until something goes wrong and you really want to talk to someone who can make a binding decision.

Not only are the big players trying to swallow up independent brokerage companies, but they’re now swallowing each other.

Consider Compass, one of the country’s largest real estate brokerage organizations. In a multibillion-dollar transaction, (billion with a B), Compass acquired Anywhere Real Estate, bringing such familiar names as Century 21, Coldwell Banker, ERA, Sotheby’s International Realty, Better Homes & Gardens, Corcoran Group, Christie’s International, properties under the same corporate umbrella. The combined organization now encompasses hundreds of thousands of real estate agents worldwide. With that many names under one corporate umbrella, a landowner might reasonably wonder just how far up the ladder a problem would have to travel before reaching someone with the authority to resolve it.

Meanwhile, Compass CEO Robert Reffkin has been making headlines challenging multiple listing services over their restrictions on how properties may be marketed. On this issue, I find myself agreeing with him. At Metcalf Land Company, we sell more than 80% of our own listings and seldom utilize the MLS, which we believe is better suited to residential real estate than specialized land transactions. We cooperate with buyers’ agents, but experience has taught us that selling land requires a particular set of skills. Ultimately, the property owner and the brokerage entrusted with its sale should have considerable latitude in determining the most effective marketing strategy. Reffkin and I might disagree about the advantages of corporate consolidation, but on this issue, we’re not very far apart.

All this corporate maneuvering raises a question that I think deserves more attention from the real estate consumer: Who actually owns the company you’re doing business with, and who is accountable when something goes wrong?

At Metcalf Land Company, the names of the company aren’t borrowed from a national organization. They belong to the people who own and operate the business. And if a client needs to speak with an owner, there are three of us who will answer the phone. We’ve been answering it since 1971 and we have no intention of stopping now.  

That’s a distinction we think is worth knowing before you sign a listing agreement, rather than discovering afterward.

Before you hire a real estate company to sell one of your most valuable assets, shouldn’t you know who owns it?